Sunday Edition: Farmers markets

Sunday Edition: Farmers markets

Editor’s Note: We’re pausing for Thanksgiving, so our next Sunday Edition newsletter will arrive in your inbox on Dec. 6. We hope you have a safe and happy holiday!

Quick bites from around the food safety arena


Today’s Topic:  Farmers markets 

The number of farms in the United States is declining, as is the total number of acres under tillage. You wouldn’t know it from the dramatic rise in the number of farmers markets in the United States. Since the mid-1990s, the number of farmers markets has increased by almost 500 percent.

Farmers markets sell food, and they aren’t unique to the United States; they exist around the world. They are popular, and they do come with food safety and fraud concerns that consumers need to be on the lookout for.

Farmers markets let local farmers sell food directly to consumers (yes, we are going with “farmers markets” without apostrophes because the AP Stylebook supports that).

With about 100 farmers markets each in New York City and Los Angeles, and more just about everywhere in between, these direct-sale venues usually enjoy a reputation for food safety among customers.

The markets may be located indoors or outdoors and typically consist of assigned spaces where farmers sell their products, which sometimes include prepared foods and beverages. 

Farmers markets differ from large public markets, which are located in permanent structures, are open year-round, and include vendors who are not farmers or producers.

By contrast, farmers markets have limited hours, seasonal availability, and food safety protocols that differ from those of traditional grocery stores. 

The consumer trends toward fresher foods that aren’t held up in transit, and toward more variety, has spurred the growth of farmers markets as a retail option. Farmers benefit from the public’s willingness to support local growers.

There have only been a few studies of the economic impacts of farmers markets, and those have not caught up with the rapid increase in the number of these venues. A 2012 study found farmers markets accounted for only a small slice of the country’s $166.9 billion in economic activity connected to farms.

A 2005 USDA study put sales from farmers markets at $1 billion. Since then, economic impacts reported by several states and cities point to the value of farmers markets and their growth.

According to supporters, farmers markets benefit both producers and consumers. Farmers can make more by selling directly to consumers than to wholesalers, food processors or large grocery firms. 

Selling directly to local consumers means produce needs less transport, handling, refrigeration, and storage time. Outdoor farmers markets also mean less overhead for land and buildings and reduced or no need for lighting and air-conditioning. 

Consumers who shop farmers markets like the reduced impact of driving and parking; fresher foods, seasonal foods and more variety for organic foods; pasture-raised and heritage breeds of meats; free-range eggs and poultry; handmade farmstead cheeses; and many less transport-immune cultivars disfavored by large grocers. And many customers just like to get to know farmers.

Overall prices at a typical farmers market are often lower than prices at supermarkets, which consumers also like.

Pros of shopping at farmers markets

  • Peak freshness and flavor: Produce is often harvested within 24 hours of reaching the market, allowing fruits and vegetables to ripen naturally rather than in transit.
  • Unique and heirloom varieties: Local growers often cultivate specialty crops, such as heirloom tomatoes, green garlic, and regional chiles, that large supermarket chains rarely stock.
  • Direct producer transparency: Buying directly from the grower lets you ask specific questions about pesticide use, soil practices and animal husbandry, aligning with Farmers Market Coalition findings that four out of five vendors discuss their farming practices with customers. 
  • Local economic and environmental impact: Dollars spent at local markets stay within the regional economy, while shorter supply chains reduce transport emissions and plastic packaging. 
  • Assistance program compatibility: Many farmers markets accept SNAP/EBT benefits and participate in matching programs (such as Double Up Food Bucks) that stretch food budgets for fresh produce. 

Cons of shopping at farmers markets

  • Limited hours and seasonality: Most markets operate only once a week for a few hours and may close or move indoors during colder months, making them inconvenient for everyday grocery runs.
  • Higher costs on specialty items: While in-season produce can be competitively priced, artisanal goods, pasture-raised meats, and small-batch baked goods often cost significantly more than supermarket equivalents.
  • Food safety and regulatory differences: Small-scale farms are often exempt from certain federal pre-sale screening rules, and outdoor booths may have limited access to running water or mechanical refrigeration, which researchers noted in a National Institutes of Health study on market food safety barriers.
  • Unverified labels and resellers: Unless a market strictly enforces a “growers-only” rule, some booths may resell conventional wholesale produce, and items are not guaranteed to be certified organic unless explicitly labeled.
  • Weather and payment limitations: Outdoor stalls are vulnerable to weather cancellations, and while mobile payments are common, some smaller vendors still prefer cash or do not trigger standard grocery store credit card reward categories. 


Our take
Farmers markets are exempt from some food safety regulations.  

If produce is sold in the same state that it is grown, it is exempt from the Food Safety Modernization Act of 2011. Exemptions for farmers markets likely contribute to a number of outbreaks and cases of foodborne illness each year.

While involving only a couple of the now thousands of farmers markets, two investigative reports in 2017 focused on the dark side of the movement.

The Canadian Broadcasting Corporation found market sales of fruits and vegetables that were not sourced from local farms. The hidden-camera report found that some stalls in one Canadian market bought produce at the wholesale market and removed the original stickers. The vendors then raised the price to 50 percent above what customers would have paid in a retail market.

At about the same time, a Tampa Bay Times reporter found some vendors at local farmers markets selling rejected produce from local wholesale markets and produce purchased from non-local sources. 

Some claimed at first that they sold the products from their own farm, but when pressed, they admitted they had grown none of the products for sale. Vendors claim the contrary; one farm in question was not growing any food, and it purchased the produce it sold at the farmers market from other companies. 

A 2015 study researched the relationship between farmers markets and food-borne illness in the United States. 

The University of Minnesota study by researchers Marc F. Bellemare, Robert P. King, and Ngoc (Jenny) Nguyen used 2004-2011 data and found a positive relationship between the number of farmers markets per capita on the one hand and, on the other hand, the number of reported (i) outbreaks of foodborne illness, (ii) cases of foodborne illness, (iii) outbreaks of Campylobacter jejuni, and (iv) cases of Campylobacter jejuni. 

The research team said: “From a policy perspective, it would be a mistake to take the results in this paper and discourage or encourage people to purchase food from farmers markets on the basis of our results. Indeed, even if our estimated relationships between farmers markets and foodborne illness were causal beyond all reasonable doubt, we cannot determine the precise mechanisms through which those relationships operate. 

“Our estimates also suggest that a doubling of the number of farmers markets in the average state-year would be associated with an economic cost of over $900,000 in additional cases of foodborne illness. When controlling simultaneously for both the number of farmers markets and the number of farmers markets that accept SNAP benefits (i.e., food stamps), we find that they are respectively associated positively and negatively with reported foodborne illness outbreaks and cases.”

The team added that “the presence of farmers markets in a given state might well lead to more cases and outbreaks of foodborne illness; this paper cannot pinpoint the precise causal mechanism through which this occurs.

“Our results are robust to different specifications and estimators, and falsification and placebo tests indicate that they are unlikely to be spurious,” the researchers said.

Fraud may creep into farmers markets when something seriously out of season is suddenly available.


By the numbers

1,755 – The number of farmers markets open for business in the United States in 1994.

4,385 – The number of farmers markets open for business in the United States in 2006.

5,274 – The number of farmers markets open for business in the United States in 2009.

8,144 – The number of farmers markets open for business in the United States in 2013.

8,863 – The number of farmers markets active in the United States in 2026, according to USDA’s Local Food Portal.

What It Means
U.S. Secretary of Agriculture Brooke L. Rollins signed a proclamation recognizing National Farmers Market Week, August 2-8, 2026.

Although that’s in the past, it’s worth noting, if only because farmers markets have become such a big deal.

Observed annually during the first full week of August, National Farmers Market Week is designed to recognize the important role farmers markets play in strengthening rural communities, creating new market opportunities for producers and connecting consumers with fresh, American-grown food.

“Every purchase at a farmers market is an investment in American agriculture, our rural communities, and our country’s future,” said Rollins.

If it’s that important, it should be worth doing new economic studies. With the rapid growth of farmers markets, it doesn’t seem right that the latest available economic data is more than 15 years old.

And do more farmers markets mean more foodborne illness, or is something else going on with human behavior?  We need some follow-up on that 2005 University of Minnesota study.

We could top 10,000 farmers markets before long. This means somebody needs to be paying attention.

Do you have any comments, questions or suggestions for future coverage? Click here to give us your feedback. 

31 Total View 6 Views Today